How to Deal with Insurance Companies After an Accident

  • Sean Chalaki
  • March 10, 2025
  • Blog
How to Deal With Insurance Companies After an Accident

When you’re injured in an accident, dealing with insurance companies can feel overwhelming. You’re already facing medical bills, time away from work, and the stress of recovery, and now an insurance adjuster is asking for details, paperwork, and statements. It’s natural to feel unsure about what to say, what to sign, and how to move forward. Insurance companies are not in the business of making things easier for you. Their primary goal is to protect their bottom line, which often means minimizing payouts, delaying claims, or even denying them altogether. Having legal guidance throughout the process can help you navigate these challenges and avoid common mistakes that could affect your claim.

How Do Insurance Companies Handle Accident Claims?

Insurance companies review claims with the goal of reducing their financial liability. Their adjusters assess accident reports, medical records, and statements to determine how much they are willing to pay. They may appear helpful, but their job is to limit payouts and settle claims for as little as possible.

From the moment a claim is opened, the insurance company looks for ways to minimize its responsibility which is why they may ask for statements, request extensive documentation, or offer quick settlements before the full impact of an injury is known. These tactics are used to control the claims process and reduce financial exposure. Personal injury attorneys understand these strategies and help claimants avoid common pitfalls that could weaken their cases.

Insurance companies are NOT on your side!

Should You Talk to the Insurance Company on Your Own?

Insurance adjusters often reach out quickly after an accident to gather information; they may ask for a recorded statement or request medical records. While they may seem friendly, their goal is to find details that could be used to reduce or deny compensation.

Providing a recorded statement is not required in most cases, and claimants should be cautious before agreeing to one. What is said in that statement can be referenced later, even if injuries worsen or if details were not fully clear at the time of the conversation. Having legal representation before engaging with an insurance company helps prevent statements from being misinterpreted or taken out of context.

What Are Some Common Insurance Tactics That Can Affect a Claim?

Insurance companies use various methods to limit payouts, often hoping claimants won’t recognize these strategies. Some of the most common tactics include:

  • Delaying the claims process – Insurance companies may stall negotiations, hoping financial stress will push claimants to accept a lower settlement.
  • Disputing liability – Even in cases where fault is clear, an insurer may argue that their policyholder wasn’t responsible or that the claimant contributed to the accident.
  • Using recorded statements against claimants – Anything said to an adjuster can be misinterpreted or used to downplay injuries.
  • Reviewing medical records for pre-existing conditions – Insurers may look for past injuries to suggest that current pain is unrelated to the accident.
  • Offering low settlements early on – Insurers often present quick settlements before the full extent of injuries is known, hoping to close the claim for less.

Personal injury lawyers recognize these tactics and work to ensure that claimants receive fair treatment. Having legal support helps prevent insurers from taking advantage of gaps in knowledge or financial pressure.

5 Mistakes That Could Ruin Your Claim

What Happens If the Insurance Company Refuses to Offer a Fair Settlement?

Not all claims settle quickly. In some cases, insurance companies refuse to provide a reasonable offer, leaving claimants with few options outside of legal action. When negotiations fail, legal representation can help determine the next steps. Filing a lawsuit does not always mean a case will go to trial, but it allows for further investigation and the opportunity to present additional evidence. It may also apply pressure on the insurance company to reconsider its position.

Attorneys prepare cases by gathering medical records, accident reports, witness statements, and expert evaluations. This information is used to demonstrate the full extent of damages and support the claim for compensation.

How Can a Lawyer Help When Dealing with Insurance Companies?

Having legal representation can help in many ways when dealing with an insurance company. Lawyers assist by:

  • Handling all communications – They speak to insurance adjusters on behalf of the claimant to prevent misstatements that could harm the claim.
  • Negotiating fair settlements – Legal professionals push back against lowball offers and provide supporting evidence to justify compensation.
  • Ensuring proper documentation – They collect accident reports, medical records, and witness statements to strengthen the case.
  • Advising on settlement offers – Before accepting any agreement, an attorney reviews its terms to ensure it covers all necessary expenses.
  • Filing legal action when necessary – If the insurance company refuses to negotiate fairly, a personal injury lawyer can pursue other legal options to seek appropriate compensation.

Talking to Insurance? Say This, Not That!

What Should You Take Away from This?

Handling the insurance claims process after an accident can be challenging. As we have discussed, insurance companies focus on reducing their liability, and without legal support, it is easy to be pressured into statements or settlements that may not be in the claimant’s best interest. Understanding common insurance tactics, securing proper documentation, and having legal representation can help individuals avoid unnecessary delays and unfair claim denials.

Legal professionals assist claimants through each step of the process, ensuring that their rights are protected and that they are treated fairly. Dealing with an insurance company after an accident is not just about submitting paperwork—it is about making sure that all damages are accounted for and that claimants receive the compensation they are entitled to under the law.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CONTACT US TODAY - 24/7

(844) 467-8487

Limited time to file your claim. Don't wait!

We’re here to help you get the compensation you deserve.

No Win. No Attorney Fees*

Start Your FREE Case Evaluation!

CALL US TEXT US LIVE CHAT

FREE CASE EVALUATION

Call us 24/7 at 844-Go-Suits or fill out the form below to receive a free and confidential initial consultation.